Toy Reviews

Cool Baker Cake Pop Maker

Cool Baker Cake Pop Maker

The Cool Baker Cake Pop Maker from Spin Master lets children (hopefully with parental participation) make and decorate very trendy cake pops. The catch is, no baking is required, as the gelatin-based mix sets in the fridge in 15 minutes before it’s ready to decorate with icing and sprinkles. No ovens, no microwaves, not even a plastic box with a light bulb like the Easy Bake Oven, suggesting this should be even easier than traditional baking.

Easier? Maybe. Less messy? Not at all.


My wife and five year-old daughter made a batch of cake pops as a mother-daughter bonding activity, and it went as you might expect. My daughter got sprinkles, icing, and cake mix everywhere, and my wife was left trying to get sprinkes, icing, and cake mix out of all the pieces that make up the Cake Pop Maker. (They also did this while I was out of the house, so unfortunately there’s no video or photos to share.)

Making the cake pops is an interesting, but somewhat over-complicated process. The cake pops are formed inside a plastic shell (created by sticking two pieces of plastic together), but rather than easily pouring or piping the cake mix into each part of the cake pops mould, you instead have to use the strange cranking dispenser on top to push out the batter. If it worked, it wouldn’t be a problem, but it seems like a case of form over function as it ended up being needlessly difficult.

But the cake pops were still made, chilled, decorated, and consumed in a relatively short period of time, which I suppose is what this set is supposed to do. Nobody bothered saving me a cake pop (it can only make four at a time), so I can’t comment on the taste first hand, but my daughter and her friend certainly seemed to enjoy them.

The biggest issue I have with the Cake Pop Maker comes down to value. For $25, you have the hardware and ingredients to create and decorate 8 cake pops. For $5 at the grocery store and a mini muffin tin, I can make a couple of dozen cake pops. If I want to make another batch, I can spend another $5 at the grocery store, while the Cake Pop Maker refills (makes four) are going to run around $7 or more. Or, I could make it from scratch, and have even fewer concerns about just what is going into these unbaked baked goods.

Bypassing the traditional baking process also means you are taking away an opportunity to share valuable life skills with your children. Instead of learning to bake, they are learning a shortcut to create sugar-laden treats.

On that note, don’t even attempt to read the nutritional information on the back of the box. Just don’t.

The GamerPops Recommendation

The Cool Baker Cake Pop Maker is very likely to be fun and messy for children, but much less thrilling for parents. The concept is a winner, but the execution and cost leave this toy somewhat, ahem, half-baked.

A review set was provided to GamerPops.

[box]If you would like to purchase the Cool Baker Cake Pop Maker, please use the Amazon links below and support GamerPops.



  • Yep you’re right! Too expensive! Too much hassle to make eight dinky pops! Their consistency is quite disgusting due to the gelatin in the mix (so they can be refrigerated instead of baked, I suppose). Refills are also way too expensive. “This is stupid!”, we shout. Instead, we pulled out my own real cake pop tin and a box of real cake mix and we made 18 cake pops the old fashioned way, in the oven. Much better 🙂 Keep your awful toy.


    My six year old daughter wanted this for Christmas. It was so difficult to use, and made such horrible cake pops, we used it ONCE and threw it away. If I could have return it, I would have, but we used up the cake mixes. Even my 12 year old son, had a hard time making the pops. They take forever, and taste horrible. The pops we did make were not even completely eaten. She ended up using the decoration materials to make cakes in her easy bake oven. My daughter, who usually get upset when I throw anything of hers away, was not even get upset when I tossed it in the trash can, IN FRONT of her. She was happy to see it go. Worst kid’s product I have bought in a long time. Save you money; do not buy this, period.

  • gamerpops

    I wish your experiences were more positive, but thank you for sharing them!

  • Lindsey

    Bought this for my kids for christmas. OMG!!!! Its super messy, doesnt fill all 4 holes an the 15 minute chill time is a joke. The batter never got hard enough and the ring was hard to take apart after the pops were so called chilled. The taste is awful. Would not buy again and is going in the trash!!!

Toy Reviews

Co-founder and Editor-in-Chief of GamerPops, Greg Picken is a husband and father of two, and lover of all things play.

More in Toy Reviews

Funko Pop Kylo Ren

Funko Pop Kylo Ren & Captain Phasma Review

Greg PickenSeptember 15, 2015
Velociraptor Claws

Jurassic World Velociraptor Claws Review

Greg PickenJuly 6, 2015
Darkside Ollie

Sphero Darkside Ollie Review

Greg PickenJune 23, 2015
Playskool Heroes Jurassic World

Playskool Heroes Jurassic World Review

Greg PickenJune 22, 2015

Cooper & Kid Subscription Box Review

Greg PickenMay 7, 2015
Lalaloopsy Diaper Surprise

Lalaloopsy Diaper Surprise Review

Greg PickenDecember 19, 2014
Innotab Max

VTech Innotab Max Review

Greg PickenDecember 15, 2014
vtech amazement park

Vtech Go! Go! Smart Wheels Ultimate Amazement Park Review

Greg PickenNovember 27, 2014
vtech smartwatch

VTech Kidizoom Smartwatch Review

Greg PickenNovember 12, 2014
Thanks for visiting!

Copyright © 2016 GamerPops. All Rights Reserved.